Welcome to Shaanxi Qianyi Tuoda Technology Co., Ltd
EnglishРусский中文
News

Titanium Cavitation & Erosion: The Film-Stripping Trap

Titanium’s corrosion resistance comes from a film only 2 to 7 nanometres thick. In a quiet tank that TiO₂ layer makes the metal almost immune. In a pump or a sand-laden line, bubbles collapsing on the surface or hard particles striking it strip the film off mechanically, and the exposed metal dissolves as a bare anode until it repassivates. That is why a Grade 2 tube that lasts years in a static acid bath can be perforated in months in a flowing slurry, and why the grade that wins a beaker test can lose an impeller. The published comparisons are sharp: in seawater, 316L stainless loses its cavitation resistance dramatically while pure titanium stays excellent; one marine pump review puts titanium at a 6.0 cavitation life factor against 4.0 for 300-series stainless and 1.0 for mild steel. This guide separates cavitation from erosion, shows where the film survives and where it does not, and ends with a twelve-line service-condition RFQ.

How to read this guide. We are a stockholder and light fabricator in Baoji, not a pump designer and not a testing laboratory. Figures below are reported from the journals, reviews and test protocols named in the field table; each is tied to its medium, velocity or temperature and method. Cavitation and erosion rates depend strongly on geometry, bubble population, particle hardness and local velocity, so a number from one rig is not a life prediction for your pump. Where the evidence cuts against titanium — lower grades in one mercury test, a surface treatment that failed — we print it too. Use this to frame the question for a pump vendor or corrosion engineer, not to size a component.

At a Glance: The Ten Facts That Decide a Wetted Part

Item Figure or finding Why it matters Status
Passive film TiO₂, about 2–7 nm Chemical resistance lives here Stripped mechanically by bubbles or particles
316L in seawater Cavitation resistance drops remarkably Pure titanium stays excellent J-STAGE 2006 rotating-disk study
Cavitation life factor Titanium 6.0 vs 300-SS 4.0 Ni-Al bronze 8.0, Monel 2.0, mild steel 1.0 Marine pump review; relative, not absolute
Steady-state cavitation rate 316 SS 0.5 / Ti-6Al-4V 0.2 mils/hr Distilled water, 20 kHz ultrasonic NBS SP394; rig-specific
Sand-laden seawater 8.2 m/s, 60 days Titanium over 100× better than 18-8 stainless Kirk-Othmer cited test
Erosion-corrosion exponent n about 2.5–3.5 on velocity Doubling flow can multiply damage 6–8× Impingement studies; medium dependent
Hard-particle threshold About 1.2 m/s for Gr2 Above it the film cannot repassivate between hits Slurry heater guidance; verify for your solid
Alloy ranking in mercury Gr5 / Ti-6242 best; Gr4 ~2×, Gr7 ~5× worse Nitriding ineffective in that test SNS study; liquid-metal specific
Film in static service Repassivates after damage Why quiet tanks are kind Mechanism, not a warranty
What this does not give A component life number Geometry and local velocity dominate Ask for rig data in your medium

How to use this table: the first three rows are the core contrast — a film that chemistry respects and mechanics can strip. For the chemistry side alone, see our failure casebook and Grade 2 vs Grade 7 seawater page; this guide is about the mechanical side.

1. The Short Answer: Corrosion Resistance Is Not Wear Resistance

Titanium is corrosion resistant because a thin TiO₂ film forms instantly on the bare metal. In a static acid bath the only attack is chemical dissolution of that film, which is slow in many media. In a moving slurry or a cavitating pump, hard particles or collapsing bubbles remove the film faster than it can regrow. The metal underneath is then active, and the area around it is still passive, so a small galvanic cell drives rapid local dissolution.

That is the whole trap in one sentence: the property that makes titanium excellent in a beaker can be switched off by the flow. A supplier quoting titanium on the strength of a corrosion table is answering the wrong question if the part sits in a pump passage or a bend. Our quote comparison guide shows how a process choice ends up as a number; here the process variable is the fluid velocity.

2. Cavitation vs Erosion: Two Ways to Lose the Same Film

Cavitation is a bubble problem. When local pressure falls below vapour pressure, bubbles form and then collapse on a surface, sending pressure pulses into the metal. The classic sign is deep pits near the trailing edge of an impeller, often with an audible crackling sound and vibration. Erosion-corrosion is a particle problem: sand, alumina or pigment grains strike the wall, fracture the brittle oxide and leave bare metal behind.

Stage What happens Result Where to look
Quiet, filmed surface TiO₂ intact, metal passive Very low chemical loss Static bath behaviour
Bubble collapse (cavitation) Shock pulses deform and fatigue the surface Film cracked, deep pits form Trailing edge of impellers; NPSH related
Particle impact (erosion) Hard grains fracture the brittle film Bare metal becomes an anode Slurries, bends, pump passages
Repassivation window Film regrows if time between hits allows Decides whether loss is small or runaway Why velocity matters more than concentration
Synergy Erosion makes corrosion; corrosion weakens the surface Total loss exceeds erosion + corrosion alone Heriot-Watt impinging-jet finding
Bend extrados Flow accelerates 1.5–2.5× bulk Impact angle 30–60° maximises loss Where slurry lines actually fail

Both mechanisms share the same dependency: whether the film can reform between impacts. That is why velocity dominates and why a static version of the same fluid can be harmless. The National Bureau of Standards study cited below describes how 316 stainless deforms at grain boundaries while Ti-6Al-4V cracks at phase interfaces and later shows a fatigue fracture mechanism — a useful link to our fatigue and surface integrity guide.

3. The Seawater Result That Breaks the 316L Assumption

A 2006 study in the Journal of the Japan Society of Mechanical Engineers compared pure titanium grades and SUS316L in seawater and tap water with a rotating-disk apparatus, and titanium alloys in 3% salt water with a vibratory apparatus. The finding is unusually clean: pure titanium’s cavitation erosion resistance in seawater is excellent, as it is in tap water, although the incubation period is shorter in seawater. Stainless steel is excellent in tap water, but its resistance decreases remarkably in seawater.

The authors explicitly say inspection intervals should be brought forward when 316L is used for a seawater pump impeller. That is a direct challenge to the habit of treating 316L as the economical marine substitute. Our marine applications page and Grade 2 vs Grade 7 seawater comparison cover the corrosion side of the same decision; the cavitation result is the part corrosion tables do not show.

If your part sits in a real flow, the enquiry needs the fluid and the velocity in its first lines. Copy these fields so a supplier can answer with service data rather than a grade name.

What to send us for an exact titanium quote

Copy these nine lines into your enquiry. A complete spec means a firm price on the first reply, not a second email asking for the grade.

Spec item Example from a real order
Grade Grade 2 (UNS R50400), commercially pure titanium
Standard ASTM B265 / ASME SB-265, current revision
Form & Size Plate, 6 mm × 1000 mm × 2000 mm, hot-rolled and annealed
Quantity 500 kg (12 sheets), one-off batch
Service medium & temperature Seawater, 30 °C, continuous immersion
MTC type EN 10204 3.1, heat-specific, with melt chemistry and tensile values
Inspection Third-party witness (SGS / BV) before dispatch; PMI on request
Target delivery Ex-works within 5 working days; FOB Shanghai on request
Drawing DXF of cut-to-size blanks, tolerance ±1.0 mm, edges deburred

Ready? Copy the nine lines above into the Requirement Details box on our Request a Quotation page and we will come back with a firm price and a dispatch date within 24 hours.

4. The Cavitation Life-Factor Table

A review of corrosion and erosion in marine centrifugal pumps gives relative cavitation life factors for impeller materials. The table is a shortlisting tool, not a service-life calculator, but the ranking is instructive.

Material Life factor Note from the review Reading
Nickel-aluminium bronze 8.0 Highest in the cited pump review Common seawater pump choice
Titanium 6.0 Second in that table Excellent in seawater, unlike stainless
Bronze 4.0 Same band as 300-series stainless Traditional water-service impeller
300-series stainless 4.0 Drops sharply in seawater per J-STAGE Fine in tap water, risky in salt water
400-series stainless 3.0 Lower than 300 series in this table Review figure
Monel 2.0 Well below titanium here Strong in many acids, not top for cavitation
Cast iron 1.5 Near the bottom Limited low-cost pumps
Brass / gun metal 1.2 Low Review figure
Mild steel 1.0 Baseline Reference point of the table

Titanium sits second, behind nickel-aluminium bronze and level with neither nor below the 300-series stainless band. The review also describes the mechanism: bubbles implode on the surface, destroy and erode the protective oxide, and the film builds up again; repetition produces the characteristic deep holes. The practical advice in the paper is to raise head pressure, reduce piping losses and turbulence, and avoid running pumps hot. Material choice is only one of the levers.

5. What the Standard Test Rig Shows

NBS Special Publication 394, “The Role of Cavitation in Mechanical Failures”, reports steady-state erosion rates in distilled water on a 20 kHz ultrasonic facility. The numbers rank the materials; they are not component life predictions.

Material Rate Condition Mechanism noted
1100 aluminium, annealed 1.33 mils/hr Distilled water, 20 kHz ultrasonic Pit lips sheared off; baseline metal
316 stainless, annealed 0.5 mils/hr Same rig Grain-boundary slip then particle fracture
Ti-6Al-4V, annealed 0.2 mils/hr Same rig Phase-interface cracks, then fatigue fracture
Ti-6Al-4V depth at 120 min 0.13 mils mean Specimen on horn tip Lowest penetration of the three
Interpretation Rates are rig-specific Not design allowances Use for ranking, not for life prediction

The study’s real contribution is the mechanism, not the ranking. Aluminium fails by shearing the lips of pits; 316 stainless by grain-boundary displacement and slip bands; Ti-6Al-4V by cracking at phase interfaces and, with longer exposure, by fatigue fracture. The authors note that cavitation response is governed by microstructural features, not by bulk mechanical properties alone. ASTM G32 is the common ultrasonic cavitation test protocol; Hielscher publishes an example protocol on annealed Ti-6Al-4V with a 45 µm amplitude at 20 °C, which shows the level of detail a meaningful test result must carry.

6. Sand, Slurry and the Velocity Exponent

In sand-laden or pigment service the damage is particle-driven, and velocity is the dominant variable. A Kirk-Othmer entry cites a high-velocity sand-laden seawater test at 8.2 m/s for 60 days in which titanium performed more than 100 times better than 18 Cr–8 Ni stainless, Monel or 70Cu–30Ni. That is an unusually strong result for titanium.

Slurry heater studies give the other side. Erosion rate follows roughly v to the power of 2.5 to 3.5, so a doubling of flow can multiply damage six to eight times. One source puts the threshold for appreciable erosion-corrosion of Grade 2 at about 1.2 m/s for hard particles (Mohs above 6) at concentrations over 5% by weight; below it the film reformed between impacts. These are application-specific figures from heater guidance, not universal limits. Our condenser tube page and coil selection guide are the product pages where this question usually starts.

7. Bends, Pump Suction and Local Velocity

Plants rarely fail where the bulk velocity is highest on paper. They fail where flow accelerates around a bend or a pump inlet. One slurry study reports local velocity at a bend extrados at 1.5 to 2.5 times bulk velocity, with impact angles of 30 to 60 degrees — the range that maximises material loss for a brittle-ductile material such as titanium. A straight tube with flow parallel to the surface sees sliding rather than impact and loses very little.

For pumps, the governing idea is NPSH: if available suction head falls below the required value, damaging cavitation occurs; between inception and required head, non-damaging cavitation may occur. The remedy list in the marine pump review is hydraulic — raise head, cut friction losses, reduce turbulence, avoid hot running. The fitting receiving-wall page and tube ordering guide show how wall and product form are specified once the hydraulics are settled.

8. Grade Choice: When Titanium Itself Disappoints

It would be easy to turn the seawater result into “any titanium beats any stainless”. The evidence does not support that. A 2010 study for the Spallation Neutron Source tested titanium alloys in liquid mercury with a vibratory horn and found weight loss fell monotonically with hardness. Ti-6Al-4V and Ti-6Al-2Sn-4Zr-2Mo were best; unalloyed Grade 4 lost about twice as much and Ti-0.12Pd (Grade 7) about five times as much, with Grade 7 especially prone to pitting.

Material Result in that rig Detail Interpretation
Ti-6Al-4V (Gr5) Best resistance in the SNS mercury test Low loss, little pitting Solid-through-thickness property in that rig
Ti-6Al-2Sn-4Zr-2Mo Also best in that test Low loss, little pitting Complex alloy, near-alpha
Unalloyed Gr4 About 2× the weight loss of Gr5 More erosion in mercury Hardness correlated with resistance
Ti-0.12Pd (Gr7) About 5× the loss, prone to pitting Worst of the grades tested there Counter-example: Pd helps corrosion, not mercury cavitation
Nitrided surface Ineffective in that test Rapid weight loss Do not assume a coating transfers
316LN, low-temp carburised Better than the best Ti alloys in mercury Rate low and manageable for both Liquid-metal specific; not a seawater result

The same study tried a nitriding surface treatment and found it largely ineffective, with rapid weight loss. That is a useful caution against buying a coating on reputation. The mercury result is specific to liquid metal and should not be read as a seawater ranking; it is printed here because a guide that only shows the wins would not be trustworthy. For corrosion-led grade selection in chlorides, our Grade 2 vs Grade 7 page is the relevant comparison.

If a pump or slurry line is already specified, send the fluid, velocity and geometry through our request a quotation page. A named engineer will tell you in writing which titanium product forms we can supply from stock and which need a corrosion or pump vendor’s sign-off — within 24 hours.

9. Silica, Alumina and Pigment: Not All Particles Equal

Particle hardness and shape move the threshold. Published slurry guidance lists approximate velocities for significant erosion: about 0.6 m/s for angular alumina (Mohs 9), 0.8 m/s for sub-angular silica sand (Mohs 7), 1.0 m/s for rounded titanium dioxide (Mohs 6.5) and above 2.5 m/s for soft calcium carbonate (Mohs 3). The harder and sharper the grain, the less flow it takes to break the film.

Local condition Behaviour What loss looks like Design response
0.3 m/s Passive film intact Pure corrosion dominates Long life in that rig
0.8 m/s Transition regime Film damage begins to outpace repair Particle dependent
1.2 m/s Approx. threshold for hard particles (Gr2) Above it, runaway erosion-corrosion Mohs > 6, concentration > 5 wt%
2.0 m/s Doubling velocity multiplies damage Reported 6–8× increase Synergy of mechanical + electrochemical
4.0 m/s Severe rate in one slurry data set Thicker wall adds little life Mitigate flow or use a harder surface
Bends and fittings Local velocity 1.5–2.5× bulk Impact angle 30–60° worst Design the layout, not just the wall

These figures come from heater and slurry guidance with their own assumptions; use them to frame questions, not to set a design velocity. The same source notes that above about 2 m/s with hard particles, a removable sleeve or a surface-hardened component can beat simply adding wall thickness, because the damage grows faster than the benefit of extra metal.

10. Thicker Wall Is Not the Whole Answer

A tempting response to erosion is to order a heavier wall. It helps in the linear regime and stops helping in the cubic one. One slurry data set reports 0.8 mm per year at 2 m/s versus 5.2 mm per year at 4 m/s — a 6.5-fold increase for a doubling of speed. At the high rate, doubling wall thickness buys only a few extra months.

The remaining wall should be treated as a measured condition, not a catalogue value. Our fitting wall receiving page describes the incoming check; the same logic applies after service. Heat exchanger and condenser designs are especially sensitive because the tube is both a pressure boundary and a heat-transfer surface. See our shell and tube heat exchanger page and offshore heat exchanger project for the equipment context.

11. Where This Guide Stops

A material article cannot fix a hydraulic problem. These are the boundaries.

Situation Why this guide is not enough What to do instead
Specifying titanium for a slurry by corrosion data alone A passive film can be mechanically removed Ask for velocity, particle hardness and concentration
Assuming 316L behaves in seawater as in tap water Its cavitation resistance drops remarkably in salt water Use seawater test data for seawater duty
Reading a life-factor table as an absolute life Those numbers are relative rankings from one review Use for shortlisting, then test the real geometry
Trusting a coating to transfer between liquids Nitriding failed in the SNS mercury test Require rig data in your actual medium
Ignoring bends and pump suction Local velocity and NPSH decide where pits start Review hydraulics with the pump vendor
Buying on grade name without surface spec Cold work and surface condition change resistance Name temper, surface finish and inspection

The fifth row is where most money is lost. A pump bought on corrosion compatibility can still chew through an impeller if the operating point sits far from its best efficiency or the suction side is starved. Put NPSH, flow and particle data in front of the pump vendor and the material supplier together. For regulated or safety-critical duties, the design authority signs off the change.

12. A Twelve-Line Service-Condition RFQ

Send these with the drawing. Lines 2, 3, 5 and 10 carry most of the risk, because they describe the flow that strips the film rather than the grade printed on the certificate.

# Field Example entry
1 Fluid and chemistry Seawater / brine / dilute acid slurry, pH
2 Solid particles Material, Mohs hardness, size, wt% solids
3 Flow velocity Bulk and local at bends, m/s
4 Component and geometry Impeller / tube / elbow / coil, ID and wall
5 Cavitation exposure NPSH available vs required, operating point
6 Temperature Bulk and surface temperature, °C
7 Target life Years of continuous service
8 Grade and product form Gr2 tube / Gr5 impeller / Gr7 vessel
9 Temper and surface condition Annealed, cold-worked, pickled, bright
10 Test basis offered ASTM G32, impinging jet, rig in real medium
11 Mitigation accepted Lower velocity, sleeve, hardened surface
12 Failure review Who analyses pits and signs off the change

Line 10 deserves emphasis. A supplier who can run ASTM G32 or an impinging jet in your actual medium is answering a different question from one who quotes a corrosion rate from a static bath. Ask what the test measured — incubation time, mass loss, mean depth — and under what amplitude, temperature and liquid.

13. Choose Titanium / Choose Bronze / Choose Something Harder

Choose titanium when seawater or chloride chemistry drives the choice and the flow is within a range the film can survive, or when the published rig data in your medium supports it. Start with Grade 2 plate, condenser tube or Grade 7 seawater heat exchanger for the relevant product form. Our heat treatment guide explains the temper behind the mechanical data.

Choose nickel-aluminium bronze when the review’s higher cavitation life factor and pump heritage outweigh titanium’s corrosion advantage, accepting the different chemistry limits. Do not assume one material wins every line of the table.

Choose a harder surface or a replaceable sleeve when hard-particle velocity cannot be reduced and wall thickness gives only linear benefit. Confirm the coating in your medium; the mercury nitriding result is a warning, not a universal rule.

Choose to change the hydraulics when NPSH, recirculation or a bend is the real cause. No material selection fixes a pump running far from its design point.

14. Why Source This From Us

We are a stockholder plus light fabricator in Baoji, the centre of China’s Titanium Valley. We will not sell titanium into a cavitating line on the strength of a corrosion table alone:

  • We ask about the flow. Roughly 800 t of titanium, nickel and zirconium stock across plate, tube, bar, wire, fittings, flanges and fasteners, and we ask what velocity and solids the part will actually see.
  • We separate stock from engineering. Standard tube, plate and fitting sizes dispatch the same day; erosive duties that need a coating, a sleeve or a vendor test are identified before the order.
  • We say when another party must decide. Pump hydraulics, NPSH and safety-critical duties belong to the pump vendor or design authority, not to a material supplier.
  • Certificates match the metal. EN 10204 3.1 MTC per heat, heat numbers hard-stamped, and inspection reports aligned with the same heat.
  • Technical answers in 24 hours. Send the service conditions and we will tell you which forms and grades we can supply from stock and where test data is needed.

Start with condenser tube, titanium tube, B265 plate, welding wire or nickel alloy stock; each page lists the forms and certification that matter for that product.

Get a firm titanium quote within 24 hours

Same-day dispatch from ~800 t of Baoji stock  ·  cut-to-size and waterjet blanks  ·  free drawing review by our engineering team  ·  EN 10204 3.1 MTC with every lot.

Request my quote →

No obligation. A named engineer replies, not an auto-responder.

EN 10204 3.1 MTC on every lot  ·  ISO 9001 quality system  ·  ASTM / ASME / GB standard literacy  ·  Third-party inspection (SGS / BV) on request  ·  Mill heat & lot traceability  ·  Export packing & full documentation

15. FAQ: Titanium Cavitation, Erosion and Wear

Is titanium resistant to cavitation?

Often yes, but it depends on the medium and the alloy. A 2006 Japanese study using a rotating disk found pure titanium’s cavitation erosion resistance in seawater excellent, as in tap water, though the incubation period was shorter in seawater. A marine pump review gives titanium a relative cavitation life factor of 6.0 against 4.0 for 300-series stainless and 1.0 for mild steel. In a mercury test for a spallation source, Ti-6Al-4V and Ti-6Al-2Sn-4Zr-2Mo performed best, while unalloyed Grade 4 lost about twice as much and Grade 7 about five times as much. Those are different liquids and rigs; ask for data in your medium.

Why is 316L stainless bad for seawater pump impellers?

The same J-STAGE study found 316L stainless had excellent cavitation erosion resistance in tap water but its resistance decreased remarkably in seawater, and recommended advancing inspection intervals when it is used for seawater pump impellers. Chloride pitting and crevice corrosion are the familiar problem; the cavitation result is the sharper one, because bubble collapse removes the passive film and the surface does not recover as it does in fresh water. Titanium held up in the same seawater test.

What is the difference between cavitation and erosion-corrosion?

Cavitation damage comes from vapour bubbles collapsing on a surface; the pressure pulses deform the metal, crack the film and form deep pits, often near impeller trailing edges. Erosion-corrosion comes from solid particles in a liquid striking the surface and stripping the protective film; the exposed metal then dissolves faster until it repassivates. Both remove the film mechanically. In slurry service they act together, and an impinging-jet study found the combined loss greater than erosion and corrosion added separately.

Does a thicker titanium wall fix a slurry problem?

Only up to a point. Published slurry data show erosion rate rising steeply with velocity, roughly with velocity to the power of 2.5 to 3.5. In one data set, doubling wall thickness added only a few months of life at high velocity because the damage scaled faster than the extra metal. The better levers are lowering local velocity, moving the component out of a high-flow zone, changing the geometry at bends, or using a surface-hardened or sacrificial sleeve. Confirm the remaining wall after service rather than assuming the nominal wall survived.

Which titanium grade is best for cavitation?

It depends on the liquid. In the spallation-source mercury test, Ti-6Al-4V and Ti-6Al-2Sn-4Zr-2Mo had the lowest weight loss and little pitting; Grade 4 was about twice as bad and Grade 7 about five times as bad. In that test weight loss fell with hardness. A nitriding treatment was ineffective. These are mercury results, not a seawater ranking. For seawater, the study cited here found commercially pure titanium excellent; ask the pump vendor for grade-specific data in your fluid.

Can a coating make titanium resist erosion?

Sometimes, but never assume it transfers. The mercury study tested a nitriding surface treatment as a way to raise cavitation resistance and found it largely ineffective, with rapid weight loss. Other reviews note that hard ceramic coatings can extend impeller life under cavitation in water service. The difference is the liquid, the impact mechanism and how the coating is bonded. Require test data from a rig in your actual medium, and specify how the coating will be inspected in service.

What should I put on an RFQ for erosive or cavitating service?

Give the fluid chemistry and pH, particle material, Mohs hardness, size and concentration, bulk and local velocity, component geometry and wall thickness, NPSH available and required if a pump is involved, temperature and target life. Ask for the grade and temper, the surface condition, and any test basis the supplier can offer, such as ASTM G32 or an impinging-jet rig in the real medium. State who reviews pits and approves a mitigation change. These lines turn a grade question into a service question the supplier can actually answer.

Summary: Ask What the Flow Is Doing to the Film

Titanium resists chemistry; cavitation and erosion attack the film that gives it that resistance. In seawater, pure titanium stays excellent while 316L loses cavitation resistance markedly; a marine pump review rates titanium at 6.0 against 4.0 for 300-series stainless and 1.0 for mild steel, and an NBS rig measured 0.2 mils/hr for Ti-6Al-4V against 0.5 for 316 stainless. In sand-laden seawater at 8.2 m/s titanium outperformed 18-8 stainless by more than 100 times, yet in a mercury test Grade 7 lost about five times as much as Grade 5 and a nitriding treatment failed. The deciding variables are velocity, particle hardness, geometry and repassivation time, not the grade name alone. Send the twelve-line service-condition checklist through our request a quotation page; a named engineer will confirm what we can supply from stock within 24 hours.Cavitation-pitted titanium pump impeller surface beside an intact impeller, magnified comparison

Need a Quote? Message Us Directly

Get live stock status, price and lead time — usually the same business day. No form required, just tap to chat.