Welcome to Shaanxi Qianyi Tuoda Technology Co., Ltd
EnglishРусский中文
Titanium Metal News

Titanium Double vs Triple Melt: What VAR Really Buys

“Triple melt” appears in aerospace purchase orders as if it were a single grade of goodness. It is not a grade and not a marketing word — it is a ladder of three metallurgical jobs, and each rung solves a problem the previous one could not. In vacuum arc remelting (VAR), melt one consolidates sponge and master alloy and begins removing gas and macrosegregation; melt two homogenises chemistry and refines the cast structure; melt three dissolves high-melting-point inclusions and lowers gas further. Double VAR is the industrial default for chemical, marine and general stock. Triple VAR is specified for aerospace, medical implant and target material. Cold-hearth melting (EBCHM or PACHM) removes high- and low-density inclusions better than VAR, and published standards already allow a single cold-hearth melt or a cold-hearth-plus-VAR route in place of triple VAR in some products. The extra rung has a price: one producer puts the third melt at roughly 40% more energy and a 50% longer cycle. This guide separates what each melt actually does, where cold hearth fits, and what to write on an RFQ so the words on the certificate mean something you specified.

How to read this guide. We are a stockholder and light fabricator in Baoji, not a melting mill, not a standards body and not an airframe design authority. Melt counts, mechanisms and cost figures below are reproduced from ChineseProducer and technical-literature sources named in the field table; the +40% and +50% figures are one producer’s published estimates, not a universal quote. Statements about AMS 6945 and grade-C material are reported as published in the cited literature — verify the current governing specification and edition with your customer or design authority before writing them into a contract. Melt practice is one input to material quality; it does not replace certificate review, ultrasonic inspection or the acceptance tests your specification requires.

At a Glance: The Nine Things the Melt Count Decides

Item What it is What it changes Status
1st VAR melt Consolidate sponge + master alloy Remove gas and macrosegregation Producer literature
2nd VAR melt Re-melt the first ingot as electrode Homogenise chemistry, refine structure Industrial default (double melt)
3rd VAR melt Re-melt the second ingot Dissolve high-melting-point inclusions, lower gas further Aerospace / medical / target
Triple vs double cost ~+40% energy, ~+50% cycle One producer’s published estimate Verify with your mill
Cold hearth (EBCHM / PACHM) High- and low-density inclusion removal Reported better than VAR for inclusions Technical literature
AMS 6945 Single EBCHM melt route Permitted for Ti-6Al-4V sheet in the cited source Verify current edition
Grade C (HM+VAR) Cold hearth + VAR Can replace grade B (triple VAR) in rotor stock Per cited literature
Macro-segregation Axial carries over, radial does not Inverting the ingot as electrode reduces it Numerical study, TC4
What melt count does NOT prove Surface finish, dimensions, final properties Still need MTC, UT and acceptance tests Scope boundary

How to use this table: the melt count answers a metallurgical question, not a grade question. To see how grade names themselves map across ASTM, GB and EN, read our grade equivalence guide; this guide is about what happens before the grade name is even assigned.

1. The Short Answer: Three Melts, Three Different Jobs

“Double melt” and “triple melt” sound like a marketing escalation, but they describe three distinct operations. Melt one consolidates sponge titanium and master alloy into a first ingot and begins removing gas and coarse segregation. Melt two re-melts that ingot as a consumable electrode to even out chemistry and refine the cast structure. Melt three re-melts again, this time to dissolve high-melting-point inclusions and lower gas further.

The useful mental model is rinsing, not grading. Each pass is the same operation applied to a cleaner input, as one Baoji producer puts it: rinse three times and the cloth is cleaner than rinsing twice. What changes is inclusion population and homogeneity, not the name on the datasheet. That is why the melt route belongs in the purchase order, not in a conversation about grade.

2. From Sponge to Ingot: The Route in One Paragraph

Titanium sponge is crushed, screened and dried, then mixed with master alloy additions such as aluminium-vanadium or nickel-molybdenum. The mix is pressed into electrode blocks, which are welded under inert gas into a long consumable electrode. Inside a vacuum arc remelting furnace an electric arc melts the electrode tip; metal droplets fall into a water-cooled copper crucible and solidify from the bottom up into an ingot. Magnetic stirring around the crucible improves mixing in the molten pool. The first ingot is cropped at head and tail, its oxidised surface is milled off, and it becomes the electrode for the next pass. That is VAR in one paragraph.

Two details matter commercially. First, the process is slow: one source puts a double-melt cycle at roughly eight days and a triple-melt cycle at roughly twelve. Second, yield is not perfect: the same producer quotes about 90 percent for the full route after cropping and surface milling. You are paying for time, energy and metal that gets cut away, which is the real reason the melt count appears in a price. Our quote comparison guide explains how process choices surface in a number.

3. What Each VAR Pass Actually Does

Pass Operation Job it does Output and handling
Melt 1 — consolidate Sponge titanium plus master alloy pressed into electrode, arc-melted in vacuum into a copper crucible Remove gas and coarse macrosegregation; make a sound first ingot First ingot; ends cropped, surface milled before re-melt
Melt 2 — homogenise First ingot becomes the consumable electrode and is melted again Further chemistry uniformity and structure refinement Double-melt ingot; the industrial default
Melt 3 — refine Second ingot becomes the electrode for a third pass Dissolve high-melting-point inclusions; further gas reduction; tighter control of arc power and vacuum Triple-melt ingot for aerospace, medical, target stock

Read the third row carefully. Its purpose is not simply “more pure”; it is a specific attack on high-melting-point inclusions that a second pass may leave behind, achieved through longer high-temperature exposure and tighter control of arc power, vacuum and hot-top time. If a supplier cannot say what the extra pass was for, the claim is a number without a reason.

4. Double Melt Is the Industrial Default — And That Is Fine

Double VAR is not an inferior product. Producers describe it as the route for industrial, chemical and marine titanium, and it covers the great majority of plate, tube and bar orders. The first pass makes a sound ingot; the second makes it uniform. For a condenser tube or a chemical vessel that is the right amount of process, and paying for a third pass without a specification that needs it is waste.

The mistake runs the other way too. If the part is a rotating aerospace component or a medical implant, “we always double melt” is not an answer. Ask which specification governs the part and let the specification decide. Our aerospace fastener bar page and Grade 2 plate page sit at opposite ends of that requirement spectrum.

If the melt route is already written into a customer specification, the enquiry should say so in the first line. Copy these fields so the supplier quotes the right process from the start.

What to send us for an exact titanium quote

Copy these nine lines into your enquiry. A complete spec means a firm price on the first reply, not a second email asking for the grade.

Spec item Example from a real order
Grade Grade 2 (UNS R50400), commercially pure titanium
Standard ASTM B265 / ASME SB-265, current revision
Form & Size Plate, 6 mm × 1000 mm × 2000 mm, hot-rolled and annealed
Quantity 500 kg (12 sheets), one-off batch
Service medium & temperature Seawater, 30 °C, continuous immersion
MTC type EN 10204 3.1, heat-specific, with melt chemistry and tensile values
Inspection Third-party witness (SGS / BV) before dispatch; PMI on request
Target delivery Ex-works within 5 working days; FOB Shanghai on request
Drawing DXF of cut-to-size blanks, tolerance ±1.0 mm, edges deburred

Ready? Copy the nine lines above into the Requirement Details box on our Request a Quotation page and we will come back with a firm price and a dispatch date within 24 hours.

5. Why the Third Melt Exists: The Inclusion Problem

The reason triple melt appears in aerospace orders is a class of defects that a chemistry certificate does not see. Nitrogen-rich hard-alpha clusters and low-density inclusions behave like embedded glass in the metal: locally hard and brittle, with a stress concentration that can start a fatigue crack before the material reaches its theoretical strength. Producer literature describes additional vacuum remelting and hot-top control as a way to dissolve these features and reduce gas content further.

This connects directly to the failure mechanism in our fatigue and surface integrity guide: the crack often starts at a local feature, not at the nominal stress. Melting reduces how many such features exist; it does not remove the need for ultrasonic inspection. The bar receiving and UT page shows the inspection layer that sits downstream of the melt decision, and the traceability guide explains how the heat number ties an ingot back to its melt record.

6. Cold Hearth: A Different Way to Solve the Same Problem

Cold-hearth melting keeps the alloy molten in a water-cooled hearth before it enters the casting mould. The two variants are electron-beam cold-hearth melting (EBCHM) and plasma cold-hearth melting (PACHM). Technical literature reports that cold hearth removes both high-density and low-density inclusions better than VAR and improves composition uniformity, which has made it a standard route for high-performance, multi-component alloys.

Route Typical application What it buys Where the cited literature puts it
Double VAR Industrial, chemical, marine, general plate/bar/tube Good cost-to-quality; standard stock Accepted where the governing spec does not demand triple
Triple VAR Aerospace structure, rotating parts, medical implant, sputtering target Reduced inclusion population, higher batch consistency Specified explicitly; one source says rotor grade will not accept double melt
Cold hearth + VAR (HM+VAR) High-performance, multi-component, high-purity alloy Better high- and low-density inclusion removal than VAR alone Grade C can replace grade B (triple VAR) in cited rotor standard
Single cold hearth (EBCHM) Ti-6Al-4V sheet under AMS 6945 in the cited source Single melt route; also closes the scrap-recycling loop AlVolatilisation under high vacuum needs compensation

Two published details are worth carrying into a conversation. In one rotor standard, grade C material (cold hearth plus VAR) can replace grade B (triple VAR). AMS 6945 is cited as allowing a single EBCHM melt of Ti-6Al-4V sheet in place of VAR or HM+VAR, with the caveat that aluminium volatilisation under high vacuum requires a compensating charge. Both are reported from the cited literature; verify the current edition and whether your customer accepts the route before relying on them.

7. The Segregation Detail Most Buyers Never Ask About

Uniformity is not only about inclusions. Macro-segregation — systematic composition variation across an ingot — can survive heat treatment and affect properties. A numerical study of triple VAR on Ti-6Al-4V found that radial variation from one ingot is removed by convection in the next melt, but axial variation carries over, and that carrying-over is weakened when the melt pool is deeper. The same study found the heaviest segregation when the ingot is always kept upright as the next electrode, and a marked reduction when at least one pass uses an inverted ingot.

Finding Mechanism Practical meaning Note
Radial composition variation Eliminated by convection in the next melt No carry-over to the next ingot Less concern from pass to pass
Axial composition variation Transferred to the next ingot Weakened when the melt pool is deeper (more convection) The persistent one
Always ingot upright as electrode Heaviest macrosegregation in triple melt Worst case in the study Avoid if segregation is critical
At least one inverted ingot pass Marks reduce macrosegregation Simple process lever Ask the mill, not the broker
TC4 (Ti-6Al-4V) Al and V Simulation matched observed segregation Confirms the model on the common alloy Source: numerical study

This is a good example of why “three melts” is not a complete answer. How the ingot was oriented between passes, how deep the pool ran and whether the melt was simulated and controlled all sit behind that number. If uniformity is critical, ask the mill about process control, not just the count.

8. What the Extra Rung Costs

Triple melt is not free, and the barriers are physical rather than bureaucratic. A Baoji producer publishes figures of roughly 40 percent higher energy and about 50 percent longer cycle for three passes versus two, alongside a full-route yield near 90 percent after cropping and surface milling. Another source cites a capital cost near RMB 100 million for a six-tonne VAR unit and notes the process is energy intensive.

Cost item Published figure What it means Use it as
Energy ~40% higher for the third melt Producer estimate, not a quote Explains part of the triple-melt premium
Cycle time ~50% longer than double VAR Two-pass ~8 days, three-pass ~12 days in one source Lead time, not just price
Yield ~90% for the full VAR route Producer figure Cropping and surface milling lose metal
Equipment High capital cost; ~RMB 100m for a 6-tonne unit cited Producer figure Why few mills do it well
What you actually pay for Time, energy, yield loss and process control Not a different grade name Read it as a process, not a label

Treat these numbers as explanation, not quotation. They show why a triple-melt bar costs more and takes longer, and why a supplier offering triple-melt pricing at double-melt lead time deserves a question. They are one producer’s estimates and should never be written into a contract as a formula.

If you are comparing quotes that specify different melt routes, send the alloy, form and governing specification through our request a quotation page. A named engineer will tell you in writing which route we can supply from stock and which needs a mill order — within 24 hours.

9. Melt Practice vs Mill Certificate: Two Different Claims

A mill certificate records chemistry and mechanical results against a heat number. A melt-route statement describes how the ingot was made. A supplier can issue a perfectly valid EN 10204 3.1 certificate for double-melt material, and that certificate does not become wrong when your application requires triple. It simply answers a different question.

This is why the route has to be specified separately. Our mill certificate page and certifications page show the document side; the melt record sits behind it at the mill. See also our heat treatment guide: melting sets the inclusion and homogeneity baseline, while downstream forging and heat treatment set the final microstructure. Neither substitutes for the other. For the document chain that ties heat to metal, see traceability.

10. Revert and Scrap Feed: The Hidden Variable

Titanium is valuable enough that scrap is routinely recycled. Cold-hearth melting in particular is used for closed-loop recovery of titanium turnings and offcuts back into ingot or billet. That is good economics, but it introduces a variable the melt count does not describe: what went into the charge.

A triple-melt ingot made from controlled sponge and master alloy and a triple-melt ingot with a high revert fraction can carry the same melt label and a different feed history. For critical parts, ask about feed source and control, not only the number of passes. This is a natural extension of the identity chain in our traceability guide and of the incoming checks on our bar receiving page.

11. Where This Guide Stops

Melt practice is upstream of almost everything else in a material decision, which means there are limits to what a count can decide.

Situation Why this guide is not enough What to do instead
Supplier says "triple melt" with no standard A melt count is a process claim, not a conformance statement Ask which specification requires it and request the melt record
Airframe / rotor application Melt route, certification and design approval interact Use the customer’s material spec; do not self-substitute
Cold hearth vs VAR decision Inclusion type and governing standard decide, not a generic ranking Ask the design authority which route is accepted
Cost estimates +40% / +50% are one producer’s figures Get a quote; do not put the percentages in a contract
Melt count alone Does not prove chemistry, properties or cleanliness Require MTC, UT and the acceptance tests in the spec
Recycled / revert feedstock Different feed history even if the melt count matches Ask about feed source and closed-loop controls

The second row is the sharpest one. For airframe and rotor parts, the customer’s material specification, qualification data and inspection regime decide the route. A supplier webpage, including this one, cannot grant a substitution. If your application is safety-critical, ask the customer’s materials department for the written requirement before you negotiate price.

12. A Twelve-Line Melt-Practice RFQ Checklist

Send these together and a mill or stockholder can answer with a process plan rather than a generic “we can do triple”. Lines 3, 4 and 12 carry most of the risk.

# Field Example entry
1 Alloy and product form Gr5 bar / Gr2 plate / Ti-6242 forging
2 Governing specification and edition AMS 4928, ASTM B348, customer material spec
3 Required melt route and count Double VAR / triple VAR / HM+VAR / EBCHM
4 Does the spec name cold hearth as acceptable Grade C / grade B / single EBCHM per AMS 6945
5 Feed material source Sponge grade, revert content, closed loop
6 Inclusion requirement HDI / LDI control, UT acceptance level
7 Homogeneity check Top / middle / bottom sampling, ICP report
8 Heat number and melt record Heat ID ties ingot to melt passes
9 Certificate format EN 10204 3.1 / 3.2, ASME CMTR as applicable
10 Inspection beyond chemistry UT, PT, macrostructure, grain size
11 Lead time for the specified route Double vs triple cycle difference
12 Who authorises substitution No substitute without written customer approval

Line 7 is worth a word. One producer describes sampling the head, middle and tail of a second ingot and measuring by ICP. Asking for the same pattern in your order turns “homogeneous” from an adjective into a report you can hold. Line 12 prevents the most expensive surprise: a substitute route discovered at receiving rather than at order entry.

13. Choose Double / Choose Triple / Choose Cold Hearth

Choose double VAR if the part is general chemical, marine or industrial stock, the governing specification does not name a third melt, and you want the normal cost-to-quality balance. Start with Grade 2 plate or Grade 12 plate for corrosion-led duties.

Choose triple VAR if the part is aerospace structure, rotating equipment, a medical implant or a sputtering target, and the specification explicitly requires it. Confirm the route in writing and expect a longer cycle; a Grade 5 bar on this route is a different process from the same grade on a double-melt route.

Choose cold hearth (HM+VAR or single EBCHM) if inclusion control or alloy homogeneity drives the choice and the governing standard accepts it. Ask whether grade C or AMS 6945 applies to your product; do not assume the route is automatically approved.

14. Why Source This From Us

We are a stockholder plus light fabricator in Baoji, the centre of China’s Titanium Valley. We will not call a melt route “triple” without saying what the claim means for your order:

  • We separate stock from mill order. Roughly 800 t of titanium, nickel and zirconium stock across plate, tube, bar, wire, fittings, flanges and fasteners, with the melt route and heat number stated for the material we actually hold.
  • We say when the mill must decide. If your part needs a specified melt route, we obtain the melt record from the producing mill rather than inferring it from a grade.
  • Certificates match the metal. EN 10204 3.1 MTC per heat, heat numbers hard-stamped, and inspection reports aligned with the same heat.
  • Honest limits. We do not present a melt count as proof of cleanliness; UT, chemistry and the acceptance tests remain part of the package.
  • Fast where it counts. Technical answers and pricing within 24 hours, stock sizes dispatched the same day, export packing and documents handled in house.

Start with bar stock, Grade 5 bar, aerospace fastener bar, welding wire or nickel alloy stock; each page lists the forms and certification that matter for that product.

Get a firm titanium quote within 24 hours

Same-day dispatch from ~800 t of Baoji stock  ·  cut-to-size and waterjet blanks  ·  free drawing review by our engineering team  ·  EN 10204 3.1 MTC with every lot.

Request my quote →

No obligation. A named engineer replies, not an auto-responder.

EN 10204 3.1 MTC on every lot  ·  ISO 9001 quality system  ·  ASTM / ASME / GB standard literacy  ·  Third-party inspection (SGS / BV) on request  ·  Mill heat & lot traceability  ·  Export packing & full documentation

15. FAQ: Titanium Melt Practice

What is the difference between double melt and triple melt titanium?

Both are vacuum arc remelting routes. In the first melt, sponge titanium and master alloy are consolidated into a first ingot and gas and coarse macrosegregation are reduced. In the second melt that ingot is re-melted as an electrode to homogenise chemistry and refine the cast structure; this double-melt route is the industrial default. A third melt re-melted the second ingot to dissolve high-melting-point inclusions and reduce gas further, with tighter control of arc power and vacuum. Producers describe double melt as typical for industrial, chemical and marine stock, and triple melt for aerospace, medical implant and target material.

Does aerospace titanium always require triple melt?

Not every aerospace part, and the answer belongs to the governing specification rather than a general rule. Technical literature cited in this guide says complex aerospace and rotor-grade alloys generally use triple VAR, and one source states that rotor-grade material will not be supplied on a double-melt route. The same literature reports that cold-hearth-plus-VAR grade C can replace grade B triple VAR in a rotor standard, and that AMS 6945 permits a single electron-beam cold-hearth melt for Ti-6Al-4V sheet. Ask the customer which route their specification accepts; do not substitute on your own.

What does cold hearth melting do that VAR cannot?

Cold hearth melting, either electron beam (EBCHM) or plasma (PACHM), keeps the metal molten in a water-cooled hearth before it solidifies into an ingot. Technical literature reports it removes both high-density and low-density inclusions more effectively than VAR and improves composition uniformity, which is why it is used for high-performance and multi-component alloys. It also enables closed-loop recycling of titanium scrap. The trade-offs are equipment cost and, for electron beam melting under high vacuum, aluminium volatilisation that must be compensated in the charge.

Why does triple melt cost more than double melt?

Because the third pass consumes more energy, takes longer and loses more metal. A Baoji producer publishes estimates of roughly 40 percent higher energy and about 50 percent longer cycle for triple VAR versus double VAR, with a full VAR route yield around 90 percent after cropping and surface milling. Those figures are one producer’s estimates, not a universal price list; the real premium depends on alloy, ingot size and mill. What you are paying for is process control and inclusion reduction, not a different alloy name.

Can a melt count prove the titanium is clean?

No. Melt practice is one input to quality. A stated number of melts does not by itself prove chemistry, mechanical properties, inclusion population or surface condition. The certificate, heat number and melt record show which route was run; ultrasonic inspection and the acceptance tests in your specification show what the metal actually contains. Treat a claim of triple melt as a process statement to be documented, not as a substitute for inspection.

What is hard alpha and how does melting affect it?

Hard alpha is a nitrogen- or oxygen-rich inclusion in titanium that is harder and more brittle than the surrounding metal and can act as a fatigue crack initiator. Published producer literature describes nitrogen-rich hard-alpha clusters and low-density inclusions as things that additional vacuum remelting and cold-hearth melting are intended to dissolve or remove. It is the metallurgical reason behind melt-count requirements in rotating parts; the fatigue consequences are covered in our fatigue guide. Melting reduces the risk, it does not make inspection unnecessary.

What should I put on an RFQ about melt practice?

Name the alloy and product form, the governing specification and edition, and the exact melt route required: double VAR, triple VAR, cold hearth plus VAR, or single EBCHM. State whether the specification accepts cold hearth, require the heat number and melt record, define the inclusion and ultrasonic acceptance level, and ask for top, middle and bottom chemistry sampling for homogeneity. Add the certificate format and lead time for that route, and a clause that no substitute melt route is allowed without your written approval.

Summary: Specify the Route, Not Just the Number

“Triple melt” is three metallurgical jobs, not a grade: consolidate and degas, homogenise, then dissolve high-melting-point inclusions. Double VAR is the industrial default for chemical, marine and general stock; triple VAR is specified for aerospace, medical implant and target material; cold-hearth routes (EBCHM / PACHM) remove high- and low-density inclusions better than VAR and, in the cited literature, grade C (HM+VAR) can replace grade B (triple VAR) while AMS 6945 permits a single EBCHM melt for Ti-6Al-4V sheet. One producer puts the third melt at roughly 40 percent more energy and a 50 percent longer cycle. Melt count is a process claim: require the heat number, melt record, MTC and UT instead of treating it as proof of quality. Send the twelve-line checklist through our request a quotation page; a named engineer will confirm which route we can supply from stock within 24 hours.

Vacuum arc remelting furnace with a titanium consumable electrode and water-cooled copper crucible

Titanium Weight Calculator — Quick Reference

All values use density 4.51 g/cm³ (commercially pure and most Ti alloys). For Gr5 / Ti-6Al-4V (4.43 g/cm³) multiply by 0.982. Figures are theoretical; actual weight varies with tolerance and surface condition.

1. Plate & Sheet — weight per square metre

Formula: kg/m² = thickness(mm) × 4.51

Thickness (mm) 0.5 0.8 1.0 1.5 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0
kg/m² 2.26 3.61 4.51 6.77 9.02 13.53 18.04 22.55
Thickness (mm) 6.0 8.0 10.0 12.0 15.0 20.0 25.0 30.0
kg/m² 27.06 36.08 45.10 54.12 67.65 90.20 112.75 135.30

Per full sheet: kg = T(mm) × width(mm) × length(mm) × 4.51 ÷ 1,000,000.

2. Round Bar — weight per metre

Formula: kg/m = diameter²(mm) × 0.00354

Diameter (mm) 6 8 10 12 15 20 25 30
kg/m 0.127 0.226 0.354 0.509 0.796 1.415 2.211 3.183
Diameter (mm) 40 50 60 80 100 150 200 —
kg/m 5.659 8.843 12.73 22.64 35.37 79.58 141.48 —

3. Tube / Pipe — weight per metre

Formula: kg/m = (OD − wall)(mm) × wall(mm) × 0.01414

Size (OD × wall, mm) 25.4×1.2 25.4×1.65 25.4×2.0 38×1.5 38×2.0
kg/m 0.411 0.554 0.662 0.775 1.018
Size (OD × wall, mm) 57×2.0 57×3.0 60.3×2.0 89×3.0 114×3.0
kg/m 1.555 2.291 1.647 3.648 4.708

For 114×4.0 mm use 6.222 kg/m. Other walls: apply the formula above.

Need the exact weight for your size?

Send us your grade, dimensions and quantity on our inquiry page — we calculate it free of charge, usually within one business day, and quote against our stock of about 800 tonnes in Baoji Titanium Valley.

Request a Quote

Cut-to-size • drawings accepted • ASTM / ASME / GB • export packing • same-day dispatch on stock items.